Effective Date: November 21, 2026
Organization: Center for Military Behavioral Health Systems (CMBHS)
Website: militarybehavioralhealth.org
The Center for Military Behavioral Health Systems (CMBHS) is committed to rigorous, transparent, and ethical scholarly publishing. This policy outlines our editorial governance, double-blind peer review standards, research ethics requirements, and post-publication accountability procedures.
1. Editorial Independence & Publication Tiers
CMBHS operates as an independent, non-partisan research and publishing hub. Editorial decisions are based strictly on empirical rigor, methodological soundness, originality, and relevance to military and veteran behavioral health systems—never on political alignment, institutional affiliation, or funding sources.
To maintain clarity between formal scholarship and timely dialogue, CMBHS distinguishes between two publication tiers:
- Official CMBHS Publications (Peer-Reviewed): Original empirical research, statutory and policy analyses, systematic reviews, and clinical program profiles published directly on
militarybehavioralhealth.org. All formal publications undergo double-blind peer review prior to publication. - The Military Behavioral Health Review (MBHR) (Editorial Commentary): Our companion newsletter on LinkedIn and Substack. MBHR features timely commentary, leadership perspectives, and accessible policy discussion. Unless explicitly labeled otherwise, MBHR essays undergo editorial review rather than formal double-blind peer review.
2. Double-Blind Peer Review Process
All formal manuscripts submitted to CMBHS follow a structured double-blind peer review process, meaning the identities of both authors and reviewers are concealed from one another throughout evaluation.
- Initial Editorial Screening (Desk Review): The Editor-in-Chief or an assigned Associate Editor evaluates each submission for scope alignment, methodological baseline, formatting compliance, and ethical adherence (including removal of author-identifying metadata). Manuscripts that fall outside CMBHS’s scope or fail basic methodological or ethical standards may be declined at this stage.
- External Peer Review: Manuscripts passing initial screening are assigned to at least two independent subject-matter reviewers with relevant clinical, operational, policy, or methodological expertise.
- Evaluation Criteria: Reviewers assess submissions on:
- Clarity of the research question or policy problem
- Methodological rigor, analytical validity, and evidentiary support
- Accuracy of statutory, regulatory, or clinical citations
- Practical relevance to military or veteran behavioral health systems
- Objectivity and clarity of writing
- Editorial Decisions: Based on reviewer feedback, the editorial team issues one of four decisions:
- Accept: Ready for copyediting and publication as submitted.
- Minor Revisions: Requires targeted clarifications or edits; verified by the handling editor.
- Major Revisions: Requires substantive methodological, analytical, or structural changes; typically returned to original reviewers for re-evaluation.
- Reject: Not suitable for publication in its current form.
- Final Decision Authority: The Editor-in-Chief holds final authority over all publication decisions.
3. Authorship & Artificial Intelligence (AI) Disclosure
- Authorship Criteria: Named authors must have made substantial contributions to the conception, design, analysis, or drafting of the work, approved the final version, and agreed to be accountable for its accuracy and integrity. Contributors who do not meet these criteria should be recognized in an Acknowledgments section.
- Use of Generative AI: Generative AI tools cannot be listed as authors. Authors may use AI tools for basic copyediting, grammar, or formatting assistance, provided they retain full responsibility for the accuracy, originality, and citations of the manuscript. Any substantive use of AI in data analysis, coding, or drafting must be transparently disclosed in the manuscript’s Methods or Acknowledgments section.
4. Research Ethics, Human Subjects & Security Compliance
Because CMBHS operates at the intersection of healthcare and national defense, all submissions must adhere strictly to ethical and security standards:
- Human Subjects Research (IRB): Empirical studies involving human participants must include a statement confirming Institutional Review Board (IRB) approval or formal exemption, along with confirmation of informed consent where applicable.
- No Protected Health Information (PHI): Submissions must never contain individually identifiable patient health information (HIPAA-protected data) or personally identifiable information (PII) of service members, veterans, or family members without documented consent and de-identification.
- Operational Security (OPSEC) & Restricted Data: CMBHS does not accept or publish classified information, Controlled Unclassified Information (CUI), or operationally sensitive military data. Active-duty service members and federal employees are solely responsible for completing any required command or agency public affairs/security clearance reviews prior to submission.
5. Conflicts of Interest & Funding Transparency
- Authors: Must disclose all financial, institutional, consulting, or personal relationships that could be perceived as influencing the research or analysis, as well as all funding sources supporting the work. If none exist, authors must include a statement declaring no competing interests.
- Peer Reviewers & Editors: Must recuse themselves from evaluating any manuscript where a personal, professional, financial, or institutional conflict of interest exists (such as recent co-authorship, direct supervisory relationships, or shared institutional affiliation).
6. Publication Integrity, Corrections & Retractions
CMBHS upholds zero tolerance for plagiarism, data fabrication, falsification, duplicate publication, or citation manipulation.
- Pre-Publication Screening: Manuscripts may be screened for originality and citation accuracy prior to peer review or publication.
- Corrections (Errata/Corrigenda): Minor errors that do not alter the core findings or conclusions of a published work will be corrected promptly via a transparent, dated correction notice appended to the article.
- Retractions: If post-publication investigation reveals serious ethical violations, fabricated data, plagiarism, or major methodological flaws that invalidate the findings, CMBHS will issue a formal, permanently linked retraction notice explaining the reason for retraction.
7. Editorial Inquiries & Appeals
Authors who believe an editorial decision was based on a factual misunderstanding of their methodology or data may submit a written appeal outlining specific point-by-point responses to the Editor-in-Chief.
For questions regarding this policy, peer reviewer applications, or editorial governance, contact:
Editorial Office — Center for Military Behavioral Health Systems
Email: shay@militarybehavioralhealth.org
Website: militarybehavioralhealth.org
